Key points
- The study ‘Same Roads, Different Rights’ examines issues involving truck drivers’ pay, accommodation and access to social protection.
- Drivers from non-EU countries may be particularly vulnerable when their residence status depends closely on their employer.
- The report calls for closer cooperation between enforcement bodies and more effective ways for drivers to file complaints.
- The German trade union ver.di is also calling for stronger checks and greater responsibility throughout the transport chain.
When the employer, dispatcher and place of work are in different countries
A driver may be employed by a company in one EU member state, receive transport orders from another country and spend most of the time working in Western Europe. The shipment itself may have been arranged by a freight forwarder based in a third country.
These arrangements are common in international road freight and are not unlawful in themselves. The problems arise when it becomes unclear which rules apply, who is responsible for the driver’s working conditions and which company the driver can turn to when seeking to enforce those rights.
Those issues are examined in the study ‘Same Roads, Different Rights’ by Giulio Benedetti of Maastricht University. Commissioned by Germany’s Equal Treatment Office for EU Workers, the report was presented in Berlin on 12 November 2026.
The research draws on legal analysis, academic literature and documented cases from advisory services. It is not a representative survey of Europe’s transport sector and cannot establish how widespread the violations described are across the industry.
Pay deductions, waiting time and life on board the truck
Unpaid wages and opaque pay systems are among the study’s main concerns. In the cases reviewed, drivers described deductions for alleged vehicle damage, excessive fuel consumption, delays and administrative costs.
Some drivers do not receive complete payslips, while others are given documents in a language they do not understand sufficiently. How pay is divided between basic wages, allowances and other payments may also be unclear.
The situation becomes especially problematic when a substantial share of income is excluded from social security contributions, potentially reducing future entitlements. That does not mean every allowance or deduction is unlawful; the outcome depends on how the arrangement is structured and which law applies.
The report also considers how transport planning can affect drivers. Tight delivery slots, long waits at loading bays and last-minute changes can create pressure when delays are not factored into subsequent trip planning. Some of the cases described involve waiting time that was not properly recorded or paid. Working time, periods of availability and rest time must, however, be distinguished under the applicable rules.
Accommodation is another recurring concern. The report describes drivers who spend long periods living almost exclusively in their vehicles. Certain rest periods may be taken in the truck, but the regular weekly rest period of at least 45 hours may not be spent in the cab. The employer must pay for suitable accommodation outside the vehicle when it is required.
Drivers from non-EU countries may be especially dependent when their residence status is closely tied to their employment, recruitment debts are involved or they rely on the employer for accommodation and their journey home.
Someone who fears dismissal or losing their prospects of remaining in the country may be reluctant to claim unpaid wages. Language barriers and constantly changing work locations can make access to advice and legal assistance even more difficult.
Why violations are difficult to identify during roadside checks
The study identifies the division of responsibilities between enforcement bodies as a major obstacle.
Roadside inspections typically focus on tachographs, driving and rest periods, and transport documents. Whether a driver has been paid correctly cannot usually be established at the roadside. Inspectors may need employment contracts, payslips and proof of payment, all of which may be held in another member state.
The report therefore recommends better-coordinated cross-border inspections, more intensive information-sharing between authorities and easier access to multilingual advice and complaints services. It also proposes a European emergency fund for stranded drivers who have not been paid. No such fund currently exists.
Germany’s ver.di trade union responded to the findings on 17 November, calling for further reforms: a single German enforcement authority for road transport, tougher sanctions and expanded powers for the European Labour Authority, known as ELA.
These are trade union demands, not measures that have already been adopted.
What this means for freight forwarders and shippers
The study also draws attention to the way transport orders are allocated.
A shipper may hire a freight forwarder, which may pass the job to a carrier. That carrier may then subcontract the work to another company. Subcontracting chains are common and are not automatically unlawful, but each additional link can make it harder to identify the company actually performing the work and to understand the driver’s employment conditions.
Transport buyers therefore need to ask practical questions. Which company will actually carry out the transport? Will additional subcontractors be involved? Are the agreed delivery windows realistic once waiting times and legally required breaks are taken into account? Are there signs of problematic employment practices?
Using a subcontractor does not automatically make the original customer fully liable for every breach of employment law. The duties involved depend on the applicable legal framework, the contractual relationships and the role played by each company.
ver.di is nevertheless calling for customers to bear greater responsibility for working conditions throughout their transport chains.
Road freight competition is affected too
The problems described in the study affect not only drivers but also transport companies that comply with the rules.
Carriers that properly account for wages, social security contributions, rest periods and accommodation must recover those costs through their freight rates. If workers are unlawfully denied payments or required to cover necessary expenses themselves, the result can be an uneven playing field.
Effective enforcement of existing rules is therefore also a matter of fair competition.
For carriers, freight forwarders and shippers, the practical lesson is not to focus solely on the transport price. Transparent contractual relationships, verifiable employment conditions and realistic transport planning matter just as much.
The study’s central finding: the more transport orders and employment relationships are spread across several companies and countries, the more important clear responsibilities and effective cross-border enforcement become.









