Ban on diesel vehicles in Hamburg has „zero effect” on air quality
You can read this article in 5 minutes
Since May last year, Hamburg has banned diesel vehicles on two busy streets. Yet, the desired effects are missing, reports the German daily Die Welt.
Traffic restrictions in Hamburg are valid from May 31, 2018 and apply to two streets in the city centre, ie sections of the road in the district of Altona-Nord, the 580-meter stretch Max-Brauer-Allee and 1600 meters Stresemannstraße (the ban only covers trucks). Truck and passenger vehicles that meet the emission standards from Euro 1 to Euro 5 cannot move there. The ban does not only apply to Euro 6 trucks and passenger cars. The police began to issue the tickets due to non-compliance on June 20. For this offense, the truck driver receives a EUR 75 penalty.
Negative effects of prohibitions
After 7 months, the time has come to summarize and assess their impact of the ban on air quality. The number of nitrogen oxides on Kieler Straße, one of the main communication arteries of the city, remained the same (44 micrograms per cubic meter), whereas pollution at Habichtstraße in 2018 decreased by 5 per cent compared to 2017. However, the value of 55 micrograms per cubic meter is still well above the recommended maximum value (40 micrograms). At Max-Brauer-Allee, the air quality did not improve at all, and the number of nitrogen oxides, despite the prohibition for older diesel vehicles, remained at the same level.
— René Ziegler (@rene_ziegler) 11 stycznia 2019
The limit values were exceeded in 2018 in all four measuring stations.
From our point of view, we can not talk about improvement,” says Manfred Braasch, managing director of the BUND environmental protection organization.
Criticism of diesel bans
However, the German forwarders and transport organizations harshly criticise the bans. Dierk Schulze, head of the company Apex Internationale Spedition commented on the new regulation right after the introduction of the ban for the portal verkehrsrundschau.de
As a freight forwarder, I say firmly: no, this is not a good idea! We lose drivers’ time because of detours. Considering the fact that the road will probably be very busy, traffic jams should be expected. It means both a waste of time and money for us,” that’s how Schulze answered when asked if the introduction of the ban in Hamburg was a good idea.
Transport associations are also looking at the next ban on older diesel vehicles with concern.
If the municipalities use the judgments of German courts as a basis for further traffic restrictions, forwarding companies, couriers and logistics, despite the modern fleet, will be able to carry out supplies for trade and city residents in a limited manner „- commented the DSLV association.
List of cities that in 2019 will introduce restrictions for vehicles with diesel engines:
– Berlin – the ban will come into force on July 1, 2019 at the latest. It will cover 11 sections on the following streets: Alt-Moabit, Brückenstraße, Friedrichstraße, Kapweg, Leipziger Straße, Leonorenstraße, Reinhardtstraße, Stromstraße. The restriction is to apply to vehicles that comply with the emission standards from Euro 1 to Euro 5,
– Bonn – the restriction will apply to Euro 1-4 vehicles and will include Reuterstraße and Belderberg. It is to enter into force on 1 April 2019,
– Darmstadt – the restriction will be introduced on July 1 this year on Heinrichstraße Hügelstraße. It will include Euro 1-5 class vehicles,
– Essen – the ban is to apply on 18 sections of roads, including also on the A40 motorway. According to the court decision, it is to be introduced in two stages: 1 July this year. for vehicles Euro 1-4 and September 1 for cars that meet the Euro 5 standard,
– Frankfurt am Main – the restriction will apply in the current eco-friendly zone. From February 1 this year vehicles complying with emission standards from Euro 1 to Euro 4 will be banned. From 1 September, the limit will apply to Euro 5 vehicles,
– Gelsenkirchen – the ban will come into effect on July 1 and will apply to vehicles from Euro 1 to Euro 5 on Kurt-Schumacher-Straße,
– Cologne -. From April 1, Euro 1-4 vehicles will not be able to move within the area of the eco-friendly zone, and from September 1 the ban will also include Euro 5 vehicles,
– Stuttgart – the ban was introduced on January 1 this year and applies throughout the eco-friendly zone. It covers Euro 1-4 vehicles.
Photo: Wikimedia/Frank M. Rauch CCA-SA 3.0