Flickr/ Department for Transport

2,650 wrong speeding alerts: England’s motorway cameras lose approval

You can read this article in 4 minutes

The Home Office has withdrawn its approval for the variable speed camera system used on England's motorways and major A roads, and National Highways is ending its enforcement contract with the supplier, Verra Mobility. Speed limits are now being monitored through traffic officer patrols, CCTV and ANPR cameras, while drivers wrongly penalised by the faulty cameras are being offered redress.

There is a person behind this text – not artificial intelligence. This material was entirely prepared by the editor, using their knowledge and experience.

Key points:

  • The Home Office has revoked the type approval of the variable speed camera system installed on England’s strategic road network from 2019.
  • National Highways is ending its contract with Verra Mobility to use the cameras for enforcement and is considering further commercial and legal options.
  • Enforcement continues through traffic officer patrols, CCTV, stopped vehicle detection radars and ANPR cameras.
  • Drivers wrongly penalised by the original fault have been offered redress, which will continue as more eligible people are identified.

A second fault found

In a written statement to Parliament on 17 November, roads minister Justin Madders explained that the problems date back to the upgrade and installation of the camera system that began in 2019.

At the end of 2025, National Highways found an anomaly in how some variable speed cameras interacted with speed limit signs. On very rare occasions, drivers were not given enough time to react to a change in the limit, or were detected speeding after the limit had already changed. The fault affected cameras on about 0.2% of roads in England.

At the time, National Highways said it had found around 2,650 erroneous camera activations since 2021 on the affected roads, which is fewer than two a day. As trans.info reported earlier this year, the issue affected 154 smart motorway speed cameras.

Since then, joint testing by National Highways and the Home Office has revealed a further potential issue with how the cameras may activate in specific circumstances, also linked to the 2019 upgrade. According to National Highways modelling, the probability of these circumstances occurring is no more than 0.1%, and the government says there is no real-world evidence that it has affected enforcement.

Approval withdrawn, contract ended

Type approval makes camera data easier to use as evidence in certain legal proceedings. The Home Office concluded that the problems could not be resolved to its satisfaction within a reasonable timeframe and revoked the type approval of the camera system.

As a result, National Highways is ending its contract with the device supplier, Verra Mobility, to use the cameras for enforcement. It is also considering all further commercial and legal options.

Who is watching speed limits now?

The government stresses that enforcement continues on all motorways and A roads, and that compliance with speed limits remains at its usual high level. National Highways has:

  • added traffic officer patrols at the relevant sites,
  • been using existing CCTV to monitor the network and drivers’ compliance,
  • kept stopped vehicle detection radars on all-lane-running sections and in emergency areas,
  • continued to use existing ANPR cameras to identify offenders.

Variable speed limit signs will still be used, so drivers must continue to follow the limits shown on the gantries. National Highways traffic officers are not police officers, but the minister’s message to drivers was clear: “if you break the law you should expect to be subject to enforcement action.”

Who pays for the wrong fines?

Everyone identified and contacted after the original fault has been offered redress, and this will continue for eligible people as they are identified. When the problem first came to light, the government said affected drivers would be contacted by the relevant police force, reimbursed and have points removed from their licence where relevant.

The government says those who were wrongly fined are being compensated, while National Highways is considering legal and commercial options against the supplier. The case was first reported by trans.info in January, when an investigation was ordered into how the problem was handled.

Review: lessons for National Highways

The government has also published the independent review led by Tracy Westall, which looked at how the original anomaly occurred and how it was handled. It identifies lessons on corporate governance, crisis management, data and technology management, and stakeholder engagement. The government and National Highways have accepted its recommendations, and improvements have already begun.

Tags:

Also read